2.2 Constitution
The VoTa Constitution provides the basis for voluntarily accepted agreements. It defines how public services must work and establishes the requirements that their operators must accept through service contracts. Citizens also voluntarily enter agreements based on the constitutional requirements for citizenship. The State is the resulting system of laws and institutions.
The VoTa Constitution is not a remote or abstract statement of ideals. It is a formal legal document whose provisions directly and unambiguously govern the duties of the judiciary, including the duty to ensure that its requirements are explicitly incorporated into service contracts, such as those for the Central Bank and the tax system. It also directly defines requirements of the citizenship contract, establishing the rights and obligations that citizens accept. Its provisions therefore have concrete legal effects through both judicial duties and the contracts binding service operators and citizens.
Article VIII: Judiciary, Section 1, requires judicial services to ensure that constitutional requirements become explicit obligations in service contracts:
When reviewing a proposed public service contract or an amendment to one, judicial services shall ensure that every provision of this Constitution governing the service is explicitly incorporated into the contract as a binding requirement on the operator implementing the service. Approval shall be refused if the contract omits, weakens, or contradicts any such requirement.
The Constitution specifies the requirements, the judiciary checks that the service contract incorporates them, and the operator accepts the contract and is bound by it. The contract may supply operational details and additional commitments, but must not weaken or override the constitutional requirements.
For example, Article XV: Monetary system defines how the Central Bank must work, including the prohibitions on borrowing, lending, and creating or destroying currency. These provisions must become explicit requirements in the Central Bank service contract, binding the operator that implements it. The Constitution can therefore continue to describe the required behaviour of the Central Bank; the service contract makes its operator responsible for providing that behaviour. Replacing the operator does not remove these requirements: the replacement contract must also incorporate them.
The same relationship applies to judiciary services, the Law Registry, the Tax Office, the Public Services Registry and other public services. Responsibilities follow the contracts each Person accepts; citizenship alone does not make a Person responsible for performing every public service obligation. This follows the principle that only Persons bear legal responsibility.
TODO: Complete the contractual framework
Article XIII: Public services, Sections 2 and 4, already requires service contracts to identify the operator and responsible Persons, define service requirements and procedures for breach and termination, and provide for transfer to a replacement operator where continuity is required. The remaining points to clarify are:
- Clarify who can enforce service-contract commitments and whether the required breach provisions adequately specify the remedies available to them.
- Specify how citizenship agreements incorporate the applicable constitutional obligations, constraints and guarantees, identify their parties and responsibilities, and establish enforcement rights and remedies, distinguishing mandatory terms from details supplied by the agreement.
- Clarify how service agreements are accepted and amended, and how citizenship agreements are accepted, amended or terminated.
- Clarify how constitutional amendments affect existing agreements.