Chapter 2: The state

Definitions used by Weber, Hoppe and Kinsella

The German sociologist Max Weber defined the state as:

A human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory.

Hans-Hermann Hoppe gives the following definition in Democracy: The God That Failed:

A state is defined conventionally as an agency that exercises a compulsory territorial monopoly of ultimate decision-making (jurisdiction) and of taxation.

This includes final adjudication of disputes involving the state itself and the power to determine unilaterally what people must pay for its services. Stephan Kinsella calls Hoppe's definition “characteristically rigorous and accurate” in The Nature of the State and Why Libertarians Hate It. These powers, rather than the mere existence of laws and institutions, are what they oppose.

Kinsella uses government to mean the institutions of governance, including law and order. In this sense, government can include anarchic arrangements without political leadership or even direct democracy. He argues that opposing the state's monopoly over these functions does not mean opposing the functions themselves, just as opposing state provision of roads does not mean opposing roads.

In David Kelley on the Necessity of Government, Kinsella objects to Yaron Brook and Don Watkins describing libertarian anarchists as wanting to get rid of government in their article Anti-State is Anti-Freedom. His objection is that anarchists need not reject law, courts or defence merely because they reject a state monopoly. That point can be accepted without adopting his terminology. Whether those functions require monopoly powers or taxation is a separate question from what we call the institutions that provide them.

Preferred definitions

The following definitions of state and government are preferred:

This is regardless of use of force or taxation.

Why these definitions are preferred

The preferred definitions fit common usage: a government administers or runs a state, and the people elect a political party to form a new government, not a new state.

Weber's definition is a definition of institutionalised aggression. If legitimacy comes from respecting rights, then no one can have a monopoly on force. If legitimacy comes from a monopoly, then it is not legitimate.

Hoppe's definition of a state likewise associates a state with compulsory monopoly powers as its defining characteristic.

Objections to coercion, compulsory monopoly and taxation do not require making these features part of the definition of a state. A definition can identify a system of laws and institutions without presupposing that it uses compulsion or that it is morally justified.

Most people associate a government with rulers that govern. Kinsella's terminology would be confusing for the VoTa constitution. VoTa has laws and institutions which don't violate property rights or monopolise decision-making, or use compulsion for taxation. Also, there is no political leadership which administers or runs the laws and institutions. Under Kinsella’s definitions, VoTa would have a government but no state. That means one can't speak of VoTa citizens as being citizens of a state. What then are they citizens of?

Weber's and Hoppe's definitions narrow the meaning of state by making coercive monopoly powers defining features. This makes it awkward to describe a system of laws and institutions that uses neither compulsion nor political leadership. Such a system still needs a name. The preferred definition allows it to be called a state without implying compulsion or political leadership.

VoTa is an example where these definitions produce opposite descriptions: government without a state under Kinsella's definitions, but a state without government under the preferred definitions. Calling VoTa a stateless government is liable to confuse readers who understand government to mean political leadership. A state without political government expresses the distinction more clearly.